Can Your Boss Fire You for Talking Back?

Can Your Boss Fire You for Talking Back?
Share This Post

One kind of insubordination is openly challenging a superior or coworker in conversation. To refuse to comply with their directives or demands. They can take action against you if you ignore their advice.

You could lose your job if you spoke back to your supervisor or other employees. If employees defy their superiors in certain states, the business cannot fire them. To be sure, this is only sometimes the case.

This article will explain the potential consequences of challenging a superior or coworker and advise how to avoid being fired.

Land More Interviews With A Professional Resume

Get a professional resume review from a certified career expert

Definition of Insubordination

The term “insubordinate” describes disrespectful behavior toward a manager or supervisor.

It includes things like:

  • Refusing to obey an order or directive from a supervisor or manager.
  • Disobeying rules set forth by a manager or supervisor. For example, if a manager tells you to stay late but decides to leave early, you would break their request.
  • Failing to carry out a direct order from a manager or supervisor. This includes ignoring requests to perform tasks or duties.
  • Making rude comments or jokes in front of a manager or supervisor. These include sarcasm, teasing, or insulting remarks.
  • Being argumentative or confrontational when asked to do something by a manager or supervisor, including telling them that they are wrong.
  • Need to follow through with agreed-upon plans or deadlines.
  • Talking back to a manager or supervisor. Even if you have a good reason for speaking up, you still could be insubordinate.

An employer does not have to prove that you were intentionally disobedient. Instead, they only need to show that you failed to comply with a reasonable request from a manager or supervisor made by company policies.

An employee who refuses to comply with a reasonable job requirement is considered insubordinate. A refusal to comply with a reasonable rule or regulation is enough to establish insubordination.

A manager or supervisor may consider you insubordinate whether or not you refuse to comply with a request. The important thing is whether or not you refuse to comply.

If you are insubordinate, your employer can take disciplinary action against you. Depending on the severity of the situation, this may mean being fired, suspended, or given a written warning.

What Happens When You Talk Back?

Suppose you are talking back to your boss. In that case, they may be trying to get you to do something that violates company policy, such as using the wrong equipment or taking too long on a task.

Sometimes, your boss might attempt to intimidate you into doing what he wants. Others might wish for someone who can follow instructions to help them complete their work.

In any event, when you talk back to your boss, you are refusing to follow their orders or directions. This means that you are acting like an adult. It also makes you appear uncooperative.

When you speak up about what you think about them or their decisions, you are showing disrespect. This is a serious offense in many workplaces, especially those where there is a lot of stress and pressure.

Your boss might try to punish you by firing you, demoting you, or giving you a poor performance review. Or, they might give you a warning or reprimand.

However, even though your boss has the authority to fire you, they don’t necessarily need to do so. They can choose to let you go without cause.

For example, under federal law, employers must allow workers to resign at any time. But, they are not required to explain why they are letting you go.

There is no statute of limitations on workplace bullying. So, suppose your employer keeps harassing you after you complain. In that case, you should file a complaint with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC).

How to Avoid Being Fired for Speaking Up

The best way to avoid getting fired is to keep quiet. Don’t challenge your boss or coworkers unless you have to.

Don’t make waves or say anything negative about them. Be polite and respectful. Never criticize your boss publicly.

Even if you disagree with their decisions, you should never voice your opinion in front of anyone else. Doing so shows weakness and puts you at risk of being punished for insubordination.

It is important to remember that you are not obligated to obey your boss or coworkers. You only have to do what you feel is right.

But if you do decide to speak out, here are some tips:

  • Make sure you know exactly what you are supposed to do before you start working. If you need more clarity about your responsibilities, ask your manager.
  • Before speaking up, consider whether the issue is worth raising. Are you concerned about a particular decision? Is there another way to handle the situation? Will your complaints help improve things?
  • Do not take matters into your own hands. If you feel your boss treats you unfairly, discuss it with your manager first. If you still believe you are being treated unjustly, contact the EEOC.
  • Keep your comments short and positive. Saying nothing will likely make your boss assume that you agree with them.
  • Try to resolve issues privately rather than bringing them up in public. When possible, raise concerns directly with supervisors instead of going through your coworker.
  • Let your supervisor know how you feel. A constructive conversation between you and your manager could help prevent problems from escalating.
  • Finally, be prepared for the consequences of voicing your opinions. If your manager doesn’t like you talking back, they may retaliate against you.

You can sue your former employer for wrongful termination if you are fired because of something you said or did. In most cases, you can collect damages such as lost wages and benefits.

In addition, you can also receive compensation for emotional distress. To do this, you must prove that your boss acted maliciously when firing you.

Consider consulting an employment lawyer who specializes in discrimination claims. The attorney can advise you on the best course of action based on your circumstances.

How to confront your boss about a workplace issue

When dealing with a difficult boss, it helps to think about why they behave the way he does. Some bosses can be extremely demanding. Others may be insecure or controlling. Still, others may be incompetent. It pays to understand why people behave as they do, whatever the reason.

Once you identify the problem, try to figure out ways to solve it. For example, you may need to work harder to earn more respect. You may need to develop better communication skills. But whatever you do, don’t let your boss get away with bad behavior.

Be careful when confronting your boss about their actions. It is common for employees to vent frustrations by complaining about their boss. However, doing so can come across as disrespectful.

Instead, try to address the problem head-on. Explain that you are concerned about their treatment of someone else. Then, offer solutions to the problem. For instance, you could suggest that your boss give certain individuals more responsibility. Or you could indicate that your supervisor should spend less time at meetings.

Remember, even though you dislike your boss, you must treat them respectfully. Otherwise, you run the risk of damaging your career.

Land More Interviews With A Professional Resume

Get a professional resume review from a certified career expert

How to fight with your boss without losing your job

It’s important to keep in mind that fighting with your boss is only sometimes a good idea. After all, if you lose control, you risk getting fired.

However, there are times when you need to stand up for yourself. Here are some tips to help you deal with a challenging boss:

First off, try to remain calm. This is especially true if you have a heated argument. Remember that yelling will only make matters worse. Instead, focus on what you want to say.

Next, consider whether you are being treated fairly. Is your boss giving you equal opportunities to succeed? Are you receiving fair pay? And is your workload reasonable?

Finally, take notes during your meeting. This will allow you to remember everything your boss says. Also, jot down any points you want to bring up later. This will ensure you remember everything important.

After you have gathered your thoughts, start by expressing how you feel. Don’t worry about sounding rude. Just state your concerns clearly. If necessary, ask permission before speaking up.

Then, explain why you believe your boss has wronged you. Try to stick to facts. Avoid making accusations unless you have proof.

If you still feel uncomfortable talking to your boss, consider asking someone to mediate between you and your manager. This gives both parties a chance to air their grievances.


Refrain from letting your anger at your manager get in the way of your work. Maintain your professionalism even if you strongly disagree with your superiors.

Doing otherwise may result in a reprimand from the higher. If that’s the case, you could not be eligible for promotions, pay increases, or other perks. In light of this, it’s best not to take things too personally.

It’s also important to reflect on past errors and correct them. You will be much more prepared the next time you encounter a situation.

Your boss can’t dismiss you for speaking up, but that doesn’t mean they won’t try. The smartest thing you can do if a disagreement with your supervisor threatens your job security is to prepare for the worst.

One of the first things you should do is update your resume to reflect your most recent accomplishments and expertise accurately. With the help of our professional resume writers, you can put together a package that highlights your qualifications and helps companies quickly evaluate you as a viable prospect. Utilize our no-cost consultation to find out how we may assist you in safeguarding your future.

Is Your Resume Working?

Get a professional resume review from a certified career expert

Is your resume getting ignored?

Land more interviews and get hired faster with a professional resume written by career experts.


Resume + Cover Letter

$ 199
  • Professionally written resume - By experts that know your industry
  • Formatted for success - Formatting that will get an employer's attention.
  • Keyword optimized - Your resume will be optimized to pass through Applicant Tracking Systems.
  • Collaborate with writer - Work directly with your resume writer for a personalized experience
  • Cover Letter - Employers are 40% more likely to read a resume with a cover letter.

Contact Us

Contact us if you have any questions

Monday - Friday, (9am - 5pm EST)


Priority Support


(786) 474 - 6976